State-of-the-Art Implementation Examples
Based on the state-of-the-art solutions studied within the scope of SP5, namely Climate Council in Munich, Building Operating System in Lyon, and Scaling Smart City Solutions in Stockholm, it has been demonstrated how citizen participation can be fostered. The solution descriptions in the Annex feature more detailed descriptions of these state-of-the-art solutions along with the technologies and digital tools, business models, funding mechanisms, procurement procedures, and governance models employed.
Technologies and Tools
- Urban Data Platforms (UDP)
- Building Management Systems (BMS)
- Information and Communication Technologies (ICT)
Funding and Monetization
- Government Grants and Subsidies
- Private Investment
- Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs)
- Service Fees and Tariffs
Governance and Procurement
- Special Purpose Vehicles (SPVs)
- Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs)
- Stakeholder Engagement
City
LyonDescription
- The Building Operating System (BOS) for virtuous behavior, operated by SPL Lyon Confluence in their headquarters, combines natural cooling, smart lighting control, and a dedicated application for staff to monitor and control office conditions, improving comfort and reducing energy costs.
Benefits
- Improves building energy performance through technology and user engagement.
- Reduces energy costs and enhances comfort for building occupants.
Governance and Procurement
- Operates under the Citizens as ICT Users business model.
- Monetization strategy relates to savings in energy bills (E_Sav_RC).
City
StockholmDescription
- The City of Stockholm, with several partners, developed an upscaling guide and tool to support the design of pilot solutions at the early stage and upscaling by the end of the pilot project. The tool includes a section on citizen consultation and participation, ensuring decision makers consider citizen participation for scaling from the beginning.
Benefits
- Supports the design and upscaling of pilot solutions.
- Encourages citizen participation, enhancing legitimacy and input for upscaling efforts.
Governance and Procurement
- Related to the Citizens as Democratic Participants or Co-creators business models.
- Process optimization savings could be a monetization strategy (D_Sav_PO).
City
MunichDescription
- Munich's Climate Council aims to increase collaboration and acceptance of energy transition measures (energy neutrality by 2035) by the civil society. It serves as a multistakeholder advisory body to support the city in achieving its climate targets.
Benefits
- Creates value for the city and citizens through better decisions and resolutions.
- Promotes a cleaner and healthier city environment.
Governance and Procurement
- Operates with elements of the Citizens as Democratic Participants and Co-creators business models.
- Potential savings in energy, health, and mobility (D_Sav_PO) through better decision-making.
These examples highlight how state-of-the-art technologies and business models can foster citizen participation and enhance public service delivery and urban management. By leveraging innovative tools and inclusive governance models, cities can achieve greater sustainability, efficiency, and community engagement.